Different gauges can do similar work, and a shooter whose favorite gauge is hard to find sometimes asks what could take its place. The honest answer starts with the payload, not the number on the barrel.
The 16 and the 20
A 16-gauge shell for upland birds typically carries about 1 to 1⅛ ounces, and Winchester's 16-gauge loads are at winchester 16 gauge shotgun ammo. A 3-inch 20-gauge shell can carry a similar payload, so a 20 gauge can do much of the 16's work. Hevi-Shot's 20-gauge shotgun shells are at hevi-shot 20 gauge shotgun shells.
The 20 gauge is also the more common gauge. Its deer slugs are at 20 gauge slug ammo for sale. Its turkey loads are at buy 20 gauge turkey loads.
The 12 and the 20
A 12 gauge has more payload room than a 20, which helps when you want heavy turkey or waterfowl loads, and its loads are at 12 gauge ammo. A 20 gauge is lighter to carry, and Winchester's loads for it are at buy winchester 20 gauge ammo.
The 28, the 32 and the .410
The 28 gauge and the 32 gauge are light gauges for small game. The 32 is rare, with Fiocchi among the makers that still load it, and its loads are at fiocchi 32 gauge ammo.
The .410 is smaller still. It can take turkeys with dense shot at short range, and Winchester's .410 turkey loads are at winchester 410 turkey loads. Remington's .410 loads are at remington 410 ammo for sale. A .410 carries much less payload than a 20 gauge, so it is a different kind of tool, not an equivalent.
Defense is a special case
Some makers market .410 loads for personal defense, and those loads are at 410 self defense ammunition. They carry far less shot than a 12-gauge defensive shell, so anyone considering one should test it in their own gun and follow local law.
Never swap shells to fit a gun
Equivalent does not mean interchangeable. A smaller shell can slip into a larger chamber and lodge in the barrel, and firing a second shell behind it can burst the gun. Shoot only the gauge and length marked on the barrel.
Payload comparisons are approximate. Never put a shell of the wrong gauge into any gun, and confirm current stock and state shipping restrictions before ordering.