Proper Methods to Create two Cash App Accounts I don’t know about you but this question often strikes my mind – can I have two Cash App accounts? Following this question when I contacted the Cash App customer service, I got more confused. Why? Because they told me that there is no right or wrong answer to this question. The creation and use of a second Cash App account are only possible when your first Cash App account has been canceled. In case your first Cash App account is still active then you will not be allowed to create another Cash App account https://cashappscontact.com/blog/two-cash-app-cards